search instagram arrow-down
Jack Weinstein

Need advice? have a philosophical question or comment?

Explore a topic:

Top Posts & Pages

Enter your email to follow PQED.

Join 3,113 other subscribers

Recent Comments

Hank Sucks on Mad Max: Fury Road is a very v…
Jack Russell Weinste… on What’s it like being Jew…
Ira Sheskin on What’s it like being Jew…
JJ on My boyfriend wants to have a t…
s. wallerstein on What’s it like being Jew…

Click image for the Why? Radio podcast

Why? Radio’s Facebook

Instagram

Twenty-eight years ago me and my horrible hair graduated @sunyplattsburgh, thanks to the mentorship of Professor David Mowry. We lost him yesterday. Read my very emotional tribute to him at www.pqed.org. #philosophy #collegife Hi listeners! Do you want to see our host Jack Russell Weinstein (@diasporajack) in person as he deejays fun and exciting music? Come down to @ojatadogmahal records this Saturday for the fourth installment of Ska and Waffles! Rehearsing for Tuesday night! Want to hear #Klezmer music live? Come to Why? Radio’s 10th anniversary party, Tuesday at 6:30. Details at www.whyradioshow.org @prairiepublic @diasporajack @empireartscenter Above two folds! Thanks @gfherald @prairiepublic ❓📩❓📩❓📩❓📩❓📩
#philosophy #ask #morals #advice #questions #help #curious #hardquestions #anything #podcast #discussion #currentevents #philosophyiseverywhere #whynot #politics #ethics #art #metaphysical #religion  #myund #questionoftheday WHY? Philosophical Discussions About Everyday Life, the Prairie Public radio show is celebrating its 10th birthday and we’re all invited to think philosophically about music with them!

Join the party for food, an interview with legendary Jazz flutist Mark Weinstein, and live Klezmer music! All for free!

For more information, visit https://goo.gl/FVRj3B or go to www.whyradioshow.org
-----
Award winning Jazz Flutist Mark Weinstein plays World Jazz and Straight-Ahead with world-class musicians rooted in the music of Cuba, Brazil, Africa, Argentina and his Jewish heritage. A Latin Jazz innovator, Mark was among the first jazz musicians to record with traditional Cuban rhythm sections in an epic album, Cuban Roots, released in 1967 with Chick Corea on piano. He also has a Ph.D. in philosophy and is a professor of Education at Montclair State University, in New Jersey. His music is the soundtrack to Why? Radio. You can learn more about him at www.jazzfluteweinstein.com 
Stay after the recording for a live concert, as Mark joins the Balkansi Klezmer Band for a jazz-infused exploration of the classic Jewish folk music, Klezmer. Balkansi is an ensemble based in Grand Forks that specializes in traditional music from one of the richest and most diverse musical regions in the world. The members of the band include Tamara Auer on violin, Haley Ellis on clarinet, Edward Morris on guitar, Zephaniah Pearlstein on cello, Michael Ferrick on bass, Rachel Agan Muniz on percussion.

And then stay even longer for an informal Q&A with Why? Radio host, Jack Russell Weinstein. 🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼🎼
@prairiepublic @whyradioshow @diasporajack @empireartscenter #logic #philosophy #podcast #jazz #flute #grandforks #music #event #klezmer #northdakota #philosophyiseverywhere #birthday #10 #markweinstein #jackweinstein #jackrussellweinstein #free #concert #interview

Follow PQED on Twitter

What is Philosophy?

Archives

A 2006 article about a “new” video game is once again being circulated on the internet. It’s probably a fake, although Snopes.com doesn’t have anything about it. The alleged game is based on the Left Behind series of books, and involves the player pretending to be in a gang of Christians killing Jews and atheists who refuse to convert. The (probably fraudulent) story has sparked outrage both from people who are offended at the violence against particular groups and by people who feel it misrepresents Christianity. There are also, predictably, people who argue that the Jews and atheists in question deserve it and others who claim that this is entirely consistent with the history of Christian power.

My reaction as a philosopher, however, is different. I ask, first, what the substantive difference is between this and the endless number of other video games that kill all kinds of people, and then I ask whether or not being rude is indeed a violation of freedom of speech.The latter, of course, forces us to ask about the relationship between the law and morality, a question that is endlessly complex.

Let me explain: First, what makes this (likely, fake) game different is that it is aimed at a particular subgroup – Jews and atheists – not enemy soldiers, robots, or egg-stealing pigs. It is easy to see why there would be outrage if there was a game about lynching African Americans or raping women, so why shouldn’t there be equal outrage if Jews and atheists are the victims? But, the opposition can argue, the game is make believe (more on this in a moment), so no actual Jew, atheist, African American, or woman, is actually being harmed, and since no one is actually being harmed, it becomes fairly easy to dismiss the outrage.

But that’s not really the argument against the game. Instead, the implicit reason for the anger is that video games shouldn’t teach hate, either in the name of Christianity or otherwise. But if this is the argument, then the game is certainly legally permissible, even if it is, on some level immoral (is it?), because declaring hate is protected by free speech. And again, if brute violence is immoral, then why isn’t Grand Theft Auto or other video games where the player kills prostitutes or, heck, anyone else who gets in their way, immoral as well? (Or, are they?)

Some Christian theologies still hold that the only way to redemption is through Christ (although certainly not all hold this opinion). Some of these also hold that violence and compulsion are acceptable means of conversion (although, in this case, these are in the vast minority). Are not these people entitled to their own video games? Again, they’re not actually hurting anyone. They’re being rude, they’re teaching hate, they’re misrepresenting a religion (most people think), but they’re not hurting anyone any more than Saw, Harry Potter, or Saving Private Ryan are. It’s all pretend. That is, it’s pretend, unless it can be shown that the video games actually inspire people to act on their hate or to hate people more than they might otherwise do without playing the video game. This is where the twist in the story comes in.

According to the article that everyone points to in their outrage,

The company is offering a free demonstration model to churches. “We see it as a beacon of light that could shine in the dark world of video games,” said Jerome Mikulich, “director of outreach ministries” for the company. “The most important thing is that it helps kids realize there is power in the spirit world, and that by praying they can endure and get through their real-life situations.”

In other words, the video game is not just teaching hate, but teaching that the slaughter of Jews and atheists is a “beacon of light,” and that people should want this to come true. So, the real objection is not that the video game is teaching people what to believe (to hate), but that it is teaching people how to act.

If this is indeed the case, what is the impermissible part, teaching people that they should act this way or people actually acting this way? No one seems to be doing the latter, just like no one actually committed suicide because Ozzy Osborne told them to. Thus, the only things that is genuinely objectionable in the story are people’s desires. Legislating against wants is a tricky business, although ironically, it is Christianity that has had the most consistent argument that individual thoughts can indeed by sinful.

On some level, a video game like this, if it were real, would infuriate me. On another level, though, I don’t even know if I would react at all. It seems totally consistent with the kind of hate and tolerance that permeates the world (and not, obviously, just from Christians). In fact, there seems to be something soothing about it being out there for all to see. To show this, I will conclude by quoting something that several different black students have said to me in private conversation over the years, all independent of one another, and most in very different geographical locations. Each of them reported that they would rather live in the Southern United States than in the North because while both regions are incredibly racist, at least in the South “you know where you stand.” In this respect, the likely-fake video game has its merits. If I am ever in someone’s house and I see it on the shelf, I know both where I stand and how fast I have to leave.

Leave a Reply
%d bloggers like this: